Don’t blame speculators for your pain at the pump, says Bill O’Grady. First blame the worldwide thirst for oil. Then blame the Federal Reserve for a cheap-money policy that makes commodities look attractive to investors.
Then blame fear, building quietly around the world, that America may someday stop being the global policeman.
O’Grady spent most of his career as a commodities guy. He followed the price of oil, gold, corn and the like at A.G. Edwards & Son.
He wrote a daily commentary on the energy markets that delved into the politics of the Middle East and drew the admiration of military officers as well as energy traders.
It was an odd place to end up for a fellow who once planned to seek God instead of mammon.
“I’d always considered being a Catholic priest,” O’Grady said. So, out of college, he signed up with the Jesuits, perhaps the most academic and intellectual branch of the priesthood.
The Jesuits have a long apprenticeship program for potential priests, and they sent him to study at for a master’s degree in economics at St. Louis University. Ironically, that helped undo his vocation.
“My first three years in the Jesuits were great. My last two, I was becoming increasingly unhappy,” he said. “I just decided I’d rather be a husband and a father than a Jesuit.”
He also found that Jesuits have a hard time with raw capitalism. “As I studied economics, and I got increasingly comfortable with the freedom that markets provide, I was increasingly at odds with the more leftist view of the world that was common among Catholic religious,” he said.
“They are very uncomfortable with markets. The basis of market economics is self-interest. For Catholics, to build your whole economic system around a human flaw is not what God put us here for,” he added.
O’Grady left before being ordained, and became as a foreign currency analyst at a small brokerage in Clayton, then moved to Mercantile Bank as an international economist, analyzing nations where the bank was lending money.
By the late 1980s, Mercantile and many other banks were losing their shirts on third-world loans, and trying to get rid of them. “We were selling Nicaragua (loans) for a nickel,” he said.
Mercantile wouldn’t need an international economist much longer, so in 1989 he signed up as a commodities analyst at A.G. Edwards, and started studying the energy markets.
That was just before the first Persian Gulf War sent oil prices through the roof. It taught him a lesson: “You can do all the supply and demand analysis you want on the oil market, but if you don’t understand the geopolitics, you’re in trouble,” he said.
So, he studied Arab, Persian and Russian history, and began writing his commentary.
O’Grady spent a couple of years studying the stock markets. After Wachovia Bank bought A.G. Edwards in 2007, he became its chief investment strategist.
He and Mark Keller, Edwards’ head of asset management, left in 2008 to form their own firm, Confluence Investment Management in Webster Groves.
There are three sorts of players in the oil market; oil producers, companies that need the oil, and investors who buy oil contracts hoping to make money on price changes. Our readers are paying almost four bucks a gallon for gas. Is that because of supply and demand, or all those evil speculators driving up the price?
In demand, there are two components. There is consumption, then everything else. Demand also includes expectations of future prices and future supplies.
What we are deeming now as speculation, is really a component of demand that is trying to address expectations of future costs.
Then we’re not at the mercy of folks that don’t really need the oil, but are just playing the game?
We want to blame those guys, saying if they weren’t here the price would be lower. That’s probably not the case.
The Fed has basically been running Fed Funds (a benchmark lending rate) below the rate of inflation since 2000. We’ve had 11 years of pretty easy monetary policy.
So people are saying, “OK, for the next five years I can either own a five-year Treasury earning 1.8 percent, or I can own oil. Oil looks like a better bet.”
In the past decade, when people weren’t comfortable with financial assets, they bought real estate. That didn’t work out so well.
Are we inflating a commodities bubble?
(O’Grady doesn’t think so.) We’re also seeing an historic shift in global growth patterns (with developing nations producing more of the world’s goods). Those countries tend to be much more resource intensive than the developed countries. China takes about three times more energy than we do to create a unit of GDP. If China’s GDP is going to grow to be as large as ours, then that is going to dramatically stretch oil, coal, uranium, natural gas